| | | Allegheny wins the toss and will defer |
| | | Case will receive and defend the north end zone |
| All | 1-10 | at All30 | ALL ball on ALL30. |
| | | Ryan Zipf kickoff 60 yards to the CASE10, B. Metlesitz return 25 yards to the CASE35 (Brad Burkley;Daniel Hafner). |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case35 | Derek Bush rush for 3 yards to the CASE38 (Joel Trembulak;Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 2-7 | at Case38 | Joey Baum pass complete to Shaun Nicely for 6 yards to the CASE44, out-of-bounds. |
| Case | 3-1 | at Case44 | Derek Bush rush for 3 yards to the CASE47, 1ST DOWN CASE (Ed Blacka;George Pappas). |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case47 | Derek Bush rush for 1 yard to the CASE48 (Sid Facaros;Shane Heschke). |
| Case | 2-9 | at Case48 | Joey Baum pass complete to Billy Deitmen for 4 yards to the ALL48, out-of-bounds (D. Williams). |
| Case | 3-5 | at All48 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 10 yards to the ALL38, 1ST DOWN CASE, out-of-bounds (Colin Hartford). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All38 | Derek Bush rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALL39 (Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 2-11 | at All39 | Joey Baum pass complete to Derek Bush for 10 yards to the ALL29 (J. Mitchell). |
| Case | 3-1 | at All29 | Derek Bush rush for 5 yards to the ALL24 (Travis Wilkins;D. Williams), PENALTY CASE holding 10 yards to the ALL39, NO PLAY. |
| Case | 3-11 | at All39 | Joey Baum pass complete to Brian Webster for 27 yards to the ALL12, 1ST DOWN CASE (Shane Heschke). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All12 | Billy Deitmen rush for 1 yard to the ALL11 (D. Williams;Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 2-9 | at All11 | Joey Baum pass complete to Brian Webster for 8 yards to the ALL3. |
| Case | 3-1 | at All03 | Derek Bush rush for 1 yard to the ALL2, 1ST DOWN CASE (George Pappas;Vince Luvara). |
| Case | 1-G | at All02 | Trevor LaBarge rush for no gain to the ALL2 (Sid Facaros;Vince Luvara). |
| Case | 2-G | at All02 | PENALTY CASE substitution infraction 5 yards to the ALL7. |
| Case | 2-G | at All07 | Derek Bush rush for loss of 3 yards to the ALL10 (John Douglas). |
| Case | 3-G | at All10 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 08:04. |
| Case | 3-G | at All10 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 10 yards to the ALL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:00. |
| | | Sam Coffey kick attempt good. |
| | | Case Western Reserve 7, ALLEGHENY 0 |
| | | Drive: 15 plays, 65 yards, TOP 07:07 |
| | | Sam Coffey kickoff 59 yards to the ALL11, Terry Hartford return 8 yards to the ALL19 (Zachary Hass;Billy Deitmen). |
| All | 1-10 | at All19 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 07:53. |
| All | 1-10 | at All19 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to David Strawser for 11 yards to the ALL30, 1ST DOWN ALL, out-of-bounds. |
| All | 1-10 | at All30 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 5 yards to the ALL35, fumble forced by Jacob Adams, fumble by Brian Tamburlin recovered by ALL Team at ALL37. |
| All | 2-3 | at All37 | Colin Hartford rush for 2 yards to the ALL39 (Adam Watson). |
| All | 3-1 | at All39 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to David Strawser for 8 yards to the ALL47, 1ST DOWN ALL (Lucas Sasala;James Wodicka). |
| All | 1-10 | at All47 | Sean Acosta rush for 3 yards to the 50 yardline (Jacob Adams;Lucas Sasala). |
| All | 2-7 | at All50 | Sean Acosta rush for loss of 10 yards to the ALL40, fumble by Sean Acosta recovered by CASE TEAM at ALL37. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 18 yards, TOP 02:44 |
| Case | 1-10 | at All37 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 05:09. |
| Case | 1-10 | at All37 | Joey Baum rush for 2 yards to the ALL35, out-of-bounds, QB hurry by William Devlin, QB hurry by J. Mitchell. |
| Case | 2-8 | at All35 | Joey Baum pass complete to Shaun Nicely for 9 yards to the ALL26, 1ST DOWN CASE (Colin Hartford). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All26 | Billy Deitmen rush for no gain to the ALL26 (William Devlin;J. Mitchell). |
| Case | 2-10 | at All26 | Joey Baum pass complete to Brian Webster for 6 yards to the ALL20. |
| Case | 3-4 | at All20 | Joey Baum sacked for loss of 9 yards to the ALL29 (Sid Facaros;Ed Blacka). |
| Case | 4-13 | at All29 | Sam Coffey field goal attempt from 46 MISSED - wide left, spot at ALL29, clock 02:21. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 8 yards, TOP 02:48 |
| All | 1-10 | at All29 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 02:21. |
| All | 1-10 | at All29 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 1 yard to the ALL30 (Lucas Sasala;Richard Doolin). |
| All | 2-9 | at All30 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Terry Hartford for 5 yards to the ALL35 (Cary Dieter). |
| All | 3-4 | at All35 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to David Strawser (Cary Dieter). |
| All | 4-4 | at All35 | Andrew Dejong punt 44 yards to the CASE21, Dan Calabrese return 8 yards to the CASE29, out-of-bounds (Joel Trembulak). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case29 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 00:48. |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case29 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 5 yards to the CASE34 (Ed Blacka). |
| Case | 2-5 | at Case34 | Billy Deitmen rush for 4 yards to the CASE38 (John Douglas). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 9 yards, TOP 04:53 |
| | | Case Western Reserve 7, ALLEGHENY 0 |
| Case | 3-1 | at Case38 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Case | 3-1 | at Case38 | Derek Bush rush for 11 yards to the CASE49, 1ST DOWN CASE (Colin Hartford). |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case49 | Billy Deitmen rush for 3 yards to the ALL48 (D. Williams;Ryan Schroth). |
| Case | 2-7 | at All48 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 10 yards to the ALL38, 1ST DOWN CASE (Sid Facaros;Craig Stamm). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All38 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 13:38. |
| Case | 1-10 | at All38 | Derek Bush rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALL39 (George Pappas;John Douglas). |
| Case | 2-11 | at All39 | Joey Baum pass complete to Derek Bush for 5 yards to the ALL34 (Ed Blacka;Zach Bell). |
| Case | 3-6 | at All34 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 11 yards to the ALL23, 1ST DOWN CASE, out-of-bounds. |
| Case | 1-10 | at All23 | B. Metlesitz rush for loss of 3 yards to the ALL26 (Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 2-13 | at All26 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to Shaun Nicely (Ed Blacka), PENALTY CASE holding declined. |
| Case | 3-13 | at All26 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 3 yards to the ALL23 (Craig Stamm). |
| Case | 4-10 | at All23 | Sam Coffey field goal attempt from 40 MISSED - wide left, spot at ALL23, clock 10:55. |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 48 yards, TOP 04:53 |
| All | 1-10 | at All23 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 10:55. |
| All | 1-10 | at All23 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 11 yards to the ALL34, 1ST DOWN ALL (Cary Dieter;Jacob Adams). |
| All | 1-10 | at All34 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Robert Carlisle for 9 yards to the ALL43 (Jacob Adams;Dale English). |
| All | 2-1 | at All43 | Tim Werley rush for 3 yards to the ALL46, 1ST DOWN ALL (Lucas Sasala;Richard Doolin). |
| All | 1-10 | at All46 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to Sean Griffin. |
| All | 2-10 | at All46 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 4 yards to the 50 yardline (Steven Roby;Mike Fioramonti). |
| All | 3-6 | at All50 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to David Strawser, QB hurry by Wade Self. |
| All | 4-6 | at All50 | Andrew Dejong punt 50 yards to the CASE0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 27 yards, TOP 02:29 |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case20 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 08:26. |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case20 | Derek Bush rush for loss of 2 yards to the CASE18 (A. Destefano;John Douglas). |
| Case | 2-12 | at Case18 | Joey Baum pass complete to Brian Webster for 5 yards to the CASE23 (James Piper). |
| Case | 3-7 | at Case23 | Joey Baum sacked for loss of 4 yards to the CASE19 (John Douglas). |
| Case | 4-11 | at Case19 | Daniel Vasil punt 36 yards to the ALL45, Terry Hartford return 0 yards to the ALL45 (Dan Calabrese). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| All | 1-10 | at All45 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 06:25. |
| All | 1-10 | at All45 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Brian Tamburlin for 37 yards to the CASE18, 1ST DOWN ALL (James Wodicka;Zachary Hass). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case18 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Brian Tamburlin for 3 yards to the CASE15 (James Wodicka). |
| All | 2-7 | at Case15 | Brian Tamburlin rush for loss of 3 yards to the CASE18 (Michael Harris;Adam Watson). |
| All | 3-10 | at Case18 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to David Strawser for 11 yards to the CASE7, 1ST DOWN ALL, out-of-bounds. |
| All | 1-G | at Case07 | Brian Tamburlin rush for loss of 3 yards to the CASE10 (James Wodicka;Dan Calabrese). |
| All | 2-G | at Case10 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to Terry Hartford. |
| All | 3-G | at Case10 | T.J. Salopek sacked for loss of 2 yards to the CASE12 (Dale English;Adam Watson). |
| All | 4-G | at Case12 | Ryan Zipf field goal attempt from 29 GOOD, clock 03:02. |
| | | Case Western Reserve 7, ALLEGHENY 3 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 43 yards, TOP 03:29 |
| | | Ryan Zipf kickoff 53 yards to the CASE17, B. Metlesitz return 18 yards to the CASE35 (A. Destefano;Ryan Schroth). |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case35 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 02:56. |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case35 | Joey Baum pass complete to Bryce Coleman for 2 yards to the CASE37 (Travis Wilkins). |
| Case | 2-8 | at Case37 | Joey Baum pass complete to Billy Deitmen for 5 yards to the CASE42 (D. Williams;James Piper). |
| Case | 3-3 | at Case42 | Joey Baum pass complete to Shaun Nicely for 19 yards to the ALL39, 1ST DOWN CASE. |
| Case | 1-10 | at All39 | Timeout ALLEGHENY, clock 02:09. |
| Case | 1-10 | at All39 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 35 yards to the ALL4, 1ST DOWN CASE (Colin Hartford). |
| Case | 1-G | at All04 | Timeout ALLEGHENY, clock 01:49. |
| Case | 1-G | at All04 | Billy Deitmen rush for no gain to the ALL4 (Joel Trembulak). |
| Case | 2-G | at All04 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 01:29. |
| Case | 2-G | at All04 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to Shaun Nicely. |
| Case | 3-G | at All04 | Joey Baum pass complete to Shaun Nicely for 4 yards to the ALL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:19. |
| | | Sam Coffey kick attempt good. |
| | | Case Western Reserve 14, ALLEGHENY 3 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 65 yards, TOP 01:46 |
| | | Sam Coffey kickoff 61 yards to the ALL9, Craig Stamm return 26 yards to the ALL35 (Lucas Sasala;Wade Self). |
| All | 1-10 | at All35 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 01:10. |
| All | 1-10 | at All35 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to Matt Griffith. |
| All | 2-10 | at All35 | T.J. Salopek sacked for loss of 5 yards to the ALL30 (Adam Watson;Richard Doolin). |
| All | 3-15 | at All30 | Brian Tamburlin rush for no gain to the ALL30 (Lucas Sasala;Dale English). |
| All | 4-15 | at All30 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 01:10 |
| | | Case Western Reserve 14, ALLEGHENY 3 |
| All | 4-15 | at All30 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| All | 4-15 | at All30 | CASE ball on CASE30. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 01:10 |
| | | Sam Coffey kickoff 61 yards to the ALL9, Craig Stamm return 17 yards to the ALL26 (Zachary Hass;Derek Bush). |
| All | 1-10 | at All26 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 14:52. |
| All | 1-10 | at All26 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 3 yards to the ALL29 (Michael Harris). |
| All | 2-7 | at All29 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to David Strawser for 8 yards to the ALL37, 1ST DOWN ALL, out-of-bounds (Mike Fioramonti). |
| All | 1-10 | at All37 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 5 yards to the ALL42 (Jacob Adams;Michael Harris). |
| All | 2-5 | at All42 | T.J. Salopek sacked for loss of 8 yards to the ALL34 (Dale English). |
| All | 3-13 | at All34 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Brian Tamburlin for 12 yards to the ALL46 (Matthew Davis). |
| All | 4-1 | at All46 | Andrew Dejong punt 48 yards to the CASE6, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:56 |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case06 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 11:56. |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case06 | Billy Deitmen rush for no gain to the CASE6 (Sid Facaros;Vince Luvara). |
| Case | 2-10 | at Case06 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to Derek Bush. |
| Case | 3-10 | at Case06 | Derek Bush rush for 2 yards to the CASE8 (D. Williams;J. Mitchell), PENALTY CASE holding declined. |
| Case | 4-8 | at Case08 | Daniel Vasil punt 38 yards to the CASE46, fair catch by Terry Hartford. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:07 |
| All | 1-10 | at Case46 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 10:49. |
| All | 1-10 | at Case46 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 8 yards to the CASE38 (Dan Calabrese;Mike Fioramonti). |
| All | 2-2 | at Case38 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Robert Carlisle for 12 yards to the CASE26, 1ST DOWN ALL (Jacob Adams;Lucas Sasala). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case26 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to David Strawser (Cary Dieter). |
| All | 2-10 | at Case26 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Brian Tamburlin for 6 yards to the CASE20 (Zachary Hass;Mike Fioramonti). |
| All | 3-4 | at Case20 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to David Strawser for 9 yards to the CASE11, 1ST DOWN ALL (James Wodicka). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case11 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 4 yards to the CASE7 (Adam Watson;Lucas Sasala). |
| All | 2-6 | at Case07 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to David Strawser. |
| All | 3-6 | at Case07 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to Terry Hartford. |
| All | 4-6 | at Case07 | Ryan Zipf field goal attempt from 24 BLOCKED, recovered by CASE Jacob Adams at CASE14 spot at CASE14, clock 07:30 (blocked by Zach Homyk). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 39 yards, TOP 05:15 |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case14 | Billy Deitmen rush for loss of 2 yards to the CASE12 (Joel Trembulak). |
| Case | 2-12 | at Case12 | Joey Baum pass complete to Shaun Nicely for 6 yards to the CASE18 (Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 3-6 | at Case18 | Joey Baum rush for 3 yards to the CASE21, out-of-bounds. |
| Case | 4-3 | at Case21 | Daniel Vasil punt 25 yards to the CASE46, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| All | 1-10 | at Case46 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 05:34. |
| All | 1-10 | at Case46 | David Tate rush for 2 yards to the CASE44 (Lucas Sasala;Michael Harris). |
| All | 2-8 | at Case44 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to David Strawser (Cary Dieter). |
| All | 3-8 | at Case44 | T.J. Salopek sacked for loss of 6 yards to the 50 yardline (Adam Watson;Lucas Sasala). |
| All | 4-14 | at All50 | Andrew Dejong punt 41 yards to the CASE9, Dan Calabrese return 11 yards to the CASE20 (Daniel Hafner;Matt Saratowski). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case20 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 04:09. |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case20 | Billy Deitmen rush for no gain to the CASE20 (D. Williams;J. Mitchell). |
| Case | 2-10 | at Case20 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to Shaun Nicely (James Piper). |
| Case | 3-10 | at Case20 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to B. Metlesitz. |
| Case | 4-10 | at Case20 | Daniel Vasil punt 33 yards to the ALL47, fair catch by Terry Hartford. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:55 |
| All | 1-10 | at All47 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 03:14. |
| All | 1-10 | at All47 | David Strawser rush for 13 yards to the CASE40, 1ST DOWN ALL (Tim Lotz;Steven Roby). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case40 | T.J. Salopek rush for 14 yards to the CASE26, 1ST DOWN ALL, out-of-bounds (James Wodicka). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case26 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 1 yard to the CASE25 (Adam Watson;Jacob Adams). |
| All | 2-9 | at Case25 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Robert Carlisle for 6 yards to the CASE19 (Steven Roby;Jacob Adams). |
| All | 3-3 | at Case19 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to Robert Carlisle (Richard Doolin). |
| All | 4-3 | at Case19 | Ryan Zipf field goal attempt from 36 GOOD, clock 01:17. |
| | | Case Western Reserve 14, ALLEGHENY 6 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 34 yards, TOP 02:04 |
| | | Ryan Zipf kickoff 58 yards to the CASE12, B. Metlesitz return 11 yards to the CASE23 (A. Destefano;Ryan Schroth). |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case23 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 01:10. |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case23 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 6 yards to the CASE29, out-of-bounds (Thomas Alderson). |
| Case | 2-4 | at Case29 | Joey Baum sacked for loss of 5 yards to the CASE24 (James Piper;Matt Myschisin). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| | | Case Western Reserve 14, ALLEGHENY 6 |
| Case | 3-9 | at Case24 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Case | 3-9 | at Case24 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 7 yards to the CASE31. |
| Case | 4-2 | at Case31 | Daniel Vasil punt 38 yards to the ALL31, fair catch by Terry Hartford. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| All | 1-10 | at All31 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 14:13. |
| All | 1-10 | at All31 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 1 yard to the ALL32 (Lucas Sasala;Adam Watson). |
| All | 2-9 | at All32 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Blake Lyle for 9 yards to the ALL41, 1ST DOWN ALL, out-of-bounds (James Wodicka). |
| All | 1-10 | at All41 | T.J. Salopek pass intercepted by James Wodicka at the CASE45, James Wodicka return 9 yards to the ALL46 (Keith Beach), PENALTY ALL personal foul 15 yards to the ALL31, 1ST DOWN CASE, 1st and 10, CASE ball on ALL31. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 10 yards, TOP 01:11 |
| Case | 1-10 | at All31 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 13:02. |
| Case | 1-10 | at All31 | Billy Deitmen rush for 1 yard to the ALL30 (William Devlin;J. Bermingham). |
| Case | 2-9 | at All30 | Derek Bush rush for 10 yards to the ALL20, 1ST DOWN CASE (Shane Heschke). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All20 | Billy Deitmen rush for 2 yards to the ALL18 (Travis Wilkins;Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 2-8 | at All18 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to Zach Homyk. |
| Case | 3-8 | at All18 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to Zach Homyk (Colin Hartford). |
| Case | 4-8 | at All18 | Sam Coffey field goal attempt from 35 GOOD, clock 11:06. |
| | | Case Western Reserve 17, ALLEGHENY 6 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 13 yards, TOP 02:02 |
| | | Sam Coffey kickoff 60 yards to the ALL10, Craig Stamm return 14 yards to the ALL24 (Wade Self;Cary Dieter). |
| All | 1-10 | at All24 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 11:00. |
| All | 1-10 | at All24 | T.J. Salopek sacked for loss of 6 yards to the ALL18 (Dale English;Adam Watson). |
| All | 2-16 | at All18 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Brian Tamburlin for 6 yards to the ALL24 (Adam Watson). |
| All | 3-10 | at All24 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to David Strawser for 27 yards to the CASE49, 1ST DOWN ALL (Mike Fioramonti). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case49 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Brian Tamburlin for 3 yards to the CASE46 (Jacob Adams;Dale English). |
| All | 2-7 | at Case46 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to David Strawser for 4 yards to the CASE42 (Cary Dieter). |
| All | 3-3 | at Case42 | T.J. Salopek rush for 3 yards to the CASE39, 1ST DOWN ALL (Jacob Adams;Lucas Sasala). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case39 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Sean Griffin for 15 yards to the CASE24, 1ST DOWN ALL (Zachary Hass). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case24 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to David Strawser, QB hurry by Jacob Adams. |
| All | 2-10 | at Case24 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to Matt Griffith, dropped pass. |
| All | 3-10 | at Case24 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Robert Carlisle for 13 yards to the CASE11, 1ST DOWN ALL (Zachary Hass). |
| All | 1-10 | at Case11 | T.J. Salopek sacked for loss of 4 yards to the CASE15 (Richard Doolin;Dale English). |
| All | 2-14 | at Case15 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Matt Griffith for 8 yards to the CASE7, out-of-bounds (Mike Fioramonti), PENALTY ALL illegal block 15 yards to the CASE30, NO PLAY. |
| All | 2-29 | at Case30 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to Robert Carlisle, dropped pass. |
| All | 3-29 | at Case30 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Brian Tamburlin for 13 yards to the CASE17 (Jacob Adams;Collin Desens). |
| All | 4-16 | at Case17 | Ryan Zipf field goal attempt from 34 GOOD, clock 06:01. |
| | | Case Western Reserve 17, ALLEGHENY 9 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 59 yards, TOP 05:09 |
| | | Ryan Zipf kickoff 55 yards to the CASE15, B. Metlesitz return 22 yards to the CASE37 (Daniel Hafner;Ryan Zipf). |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case37 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 05:51. |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case37 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 12 yards to the CASE49, 1ST DOWN CASE (Colin Hartford). |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case49 | Derek Bush rush for 9 yards to the ALL42 (Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 2-1 | at All42 | Trevor LaBarge rush for 2 yards to the ALL40, 1ST DOWN CASE (Joel Trembulak;J. Mitchell). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All40 | Derek Bush rush for no gain to the ALL40 (D. Williams;Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 2-10 | at All40 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 10 yards to the ALL30, 1ST DOWN CASE (Colin Hartford;Ryan Schroth). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All30 | Derek Bush rush for 1 yard to the ALL29 (Joel Trembulak;J. Mitchell). |
| Case | 2-9 | at All29 | Timeout Case Western Reserve, clock 02:07. |
| Case | 2-9 | at All29 | Joey Baum pass complete to Shaun Nicely for 15 yards to the ALL14, 1ST DOWN CASE, out-of-bounds (Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All14 | Derek Bush rush for loss of 10 yards to the ALL24, fumble forced by Ed Blacka, fumble by Derek Bush recovered by ALL Sid Facaros at ALL24, Sid Facaros for 76 yards to the CASE0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:46. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 39 yards, TOP 04:05 |
| All | 1-G | at Case03 | Timeout ALLEGHENY, clock 01:46. |
| All | 1-G | at Case03 | Timeout ALLEGHENY, clock 01:46. |
| | | T.J. Salopek pass attempt to David Strawser good. |
| | | ALLEGHENY 17, Case Western Reserve 17 |
| | | Ryan Zipf kickoff 57 yards to the CASE13, B. Metlesitz return 25 yards to the CASE38 (Robert Carlisle). |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case38 | CASE WESTERN RESERVE drive start at 01:41. |
| Case | 1-10 | at Case38 | Joey Baum pass complete to Shaun Nicely for 18 yards to the ALL44, 1ST DOWN CASE, out-of-bounds (Shane Heschke). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All44 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to Shaun Nicely. |
| Case | 2-10 | at All44 | Joey Baum rush for loss of 5 yards to the ALL49. |
| Case | 3-15 | at All49 | Joey Baum pass incomplete to Shaun Nicely, QB hurry by Joel Trembulak. |
| Case | 4-15 | at All49 | Daniel Vasil punt 24 yards to the ALL25, fair catch by Terry Hartford. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 13 yards, TOP 00:42 |
| All | 1-10 | at All25 | ALLEGHENY drive start at 00:59. |
| All | 1-10 | at All25 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 5 yards to the ALL30 (Dan Calabrese;Wade Self). |
| All | 2-5 | at All30 | Team rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALL28. |
| All | 3-7 | at All28 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| | | ALLEGHENY 17, Case Western Reserve 17 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| | | Case Western Reserve 24, ALLEGHENY 23 |
| All | 3-7 | at All28 | Start of OT quarter, clock 15:00. |
| | | Allegheny wins the toss and elects to go on defense first |
| All | 3-7 | at All28 | CASE ball on ALL25. |
| Case | 3-7 | at All25 | 1st and 10. |
| Case | 1-10 | at All25 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 6 yards to the ALL19 (Ed Blacka;Colin Hartford). |
| Case | 2-4 | at All19 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 3 yards to the ALL16 (Craig Stamm). |
| Case | 3-1 | at All16 | Joey Baum pass complete to Zach Homyk for 2 yards to the ALL14, 1ST DOWN CASE (Zach Bell). |
| Case | 1-10 | at All14 | Billy Deitmen rush for 6 yards to the ALL8 (Shane Heschke;Sid Facaros). |
| Case | 2-4 | at All08 | Billy Deitmen rush for 2 yards to the ALL6 (D. Williams;J. Mitchell). |
| Case | 3-2 | at All06 | Joey Baum pass complete to Shaun Nicely for 6 yards to the ALL0, 1ST DOWN CASE, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| | | Sam Coffey kick attempt good. |
| | | Case Western Reserve 24, ALLEGHENY 17 |
| Case | 1-G | at Case30 | ALL ball on CASE25. |
| All | 1-G | at Case25 | 1st and 10. |
| All | 1-10 | at Case25 | T.J. Salopek rush for 2 yards to the CASE23 (Dan Calabrese). |
| All | 2-8 | at Case23 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to Robert Carlisle, dropped pass (Jacob Adams), PENALTY CASE pass interference 6 yards to the CASE17, 1ST DOWN ALL, NO PLAY. |
| All | 1-10 | at Case17 | T.J. Salopek rush for no gain to the CASE17, fumble by T.J. Salopek recovered by ALL Brian Tamburlin at CASE23. |
| All | 2-16 | at Case23 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Matt Griffith for 17 yards to the CASE6, 1ST DOWN ALL, PENALTY CASE pass interference declined. |
| All | 1-G | at Case06 | Brian Tamburlin rush for 1 yard to the CASE5 (Dale English;Jacob Adams). |
| All | 2-G | at Case05 | T.J. Salopek pass incomplete to David Strawser. |
| All | 3-G | at Case05 | T.J. Salopek pass complete to Terry Hartford for 5 yards to the CASE0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| | | Ryan Zipf kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Jacob Adams). |
| | | Case Western Reserve 24, ALLEGHENY 23 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| | | Case Western Reserve 24, ALLEGHENY 23 |