| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 06, 2009 | Springfield, Ohio | Wittenberg 3, Allegheny 0 (25-17,25-15,25-19) | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Case Western Reserve 3, Allegheny 1 (25-19,25-27,25-20,25-11) | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 3, Denison 0 (25-19,25-21,26-24) | Box score |
| Oct 28, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Penn State Behrend 3, Allegheny 0 (25-23,25-16,27-25) | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Gambier, Ohio | Defiance 3, Allegheny 1 (25-20,18-25,25-19,25-18) | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Gambier, Ohio | Allegheny 3, Kenyon 0 (25-22,25-21,25-19) | Box score |
| Oct 21, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 3, Oberlin 1 (23-25,25-17,25-19,25-8) | Box score |
| Oct 18, 2009 | Richmond, Ind. | Wooster 3, Allegheny 0 (25-13,26-24,25-18) | Box score |
| Oct 18, 2009 | Richmond, Ind. | Allegheny 3, Earlham 0 (25-19,25-21,25-19) | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Richmond, Ind. | Wittenberg 3, Allegheny 0 (25-21,25-17,25-20) | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Richmond, Ind. | Allegheny 3, Oberlin 2 (25-20,13-25,14-25,25-17,15-12) | Box score |
| Oct 14, 2009 | Wooster, Ohio | Wooster 3, Allegheny 2 (21-25,28-26,20-25,25-19,15-10) | Box score |
| Oct 10, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 3, Earlham 0 (25-19,25-15,25-22) | Box score |
| Oct 9, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Wittenberg 3, Allegheny 0 (25-16,25-18,25-15) | Box score |
| Oct 06, 2009 | Hiram, Ohio | Hiram 3, Allegheny 0 (25-22,25-14,25-17) | Box score |
| Oct 03, 2009 | Delaware, Ohio | Allegheny 3, Ohio Wesleyan 0 (25-22,25-21,25-19) | Box score |
| Sep 27, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 3, Kenyon 0 (25-20,25-19,25-7) | Box score |
| Sep 27, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 3, Ohio Wesleyan 0 (25-17,25-12,25-21) | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Hiram 3, Allegheny 2 (21-25,20-25,25-21,25-13,15-13) | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 3, Denison 1 (25-14,23-25,25-21,27-25) | Box score |
| Sep 23, 2009 | Grove City, Pa. | Allegheny 3, Grove City 1 (25-23,25-22,17-25,25-20) | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Salisbury, Md. | Haverford 3, Allegheny 0 (25-22,25-13,25-21) | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Salisbury, Md. | Salisbury 3, Allegheny 1 (25-19,25-10,23-25,27-25) | Box score |
| Sep 18, 2009 | Salisbury, Md. | Allegheny 3, Baldwin-Wallace 1 (25-13,25-19,23-25,25-17) | Box score |
| Sep 18, 2009 | Salisbury, Md. | Allegheny 3, Richard Stockton 1 (25-20,23-25,25-20,27-25) | Box score |
| Sep 15, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 3, Fredonia State 1 (25-19,25-22,21-25,25-22) | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Rochester, N.Y. | New Paltz 3, Allegheny 1 (25-21,22-25,25-20,27-25) | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Rochester, N.Y. | Allegheny 3, Nazareth 1 (8-25,25-18,25-16,25-21) | Box score |
| Sep 11, 2009 | Rochester, N.Y. | Allegheny 3, Sage 1 (25-11,19-25,25-12,25-12) | Box score |
| Sep 11, 2009 | Rochester, N.Y. | Cortland 3, Allegheny 0 (25-17,25-17,25-20) | Box score |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | Penn State Altoona 3, Allegheny 1 (27-29,25-18,25-16,25-21) | Box score |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | Captial 3, Allegheny 0 (25-15,25-10,25-20) | Box score |
| Sep 04, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | Hanover 3, Allegheny 1 (25-21,20-25,25-17,25-19) | Box score |
| Sep 04, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | Albion 3, Allegheny 2 (22-25,25-19,22-25,25-23,15-12) | Box score |